Arguably one of the toughest places to get a dinner reservation, whether in Margate or anywhere in South Jersey.
Steve and Cookie’s on Amherst Ave. A former supper club built circa 1932.
Now in it’s 27th year on the bay in Margate.
Steve & Cookie’s Reservations. According to their website, here’s how to get a table.
Step#1. Reservations must be made through Resy.
Reservations are for indoor dining only. They become available exactly 30 days prior to the desired date, right at 10am.
8 guests is the largest possible party size accommodated.
Very limited on tables that can accommodate more than 4 guests.
Visit the Resy website or app.
Credit cards required for all reservations. If you fail to cancel your reservation and do not show up, you will be charged a $25 per person no show fee.
If you need to cancel, you may do so on the Resy app or by calling (609)823-1163.
Leave a message if no answer.Â
Once you book a reservation, please (!) make sure you receive a booking confirmation email from Resy. It’s the easiest way to confirm that your reservation was made and went through.
If you don’t receive a confirmation email and believe you made a reservation, call (609)823-1163.Â
If Steve and Cookie’s is fully booked for reservations, you can place your name on the Notify list. It is a virtual waitlist through Resy and they will notify you via a push notification if anything becomes available during your desired time frame.
There will be no outdoor tables under the tent for dining this summer at Steve and Cookies.
The outdoor bar will be open with 8 dining seats that will be first come, first served and provide the full menu.
The outdoor bar will also have a window available for walk-up drinks, with adirondack chairs for lounging.
The rest of Steve and Cookies’ bars and oyster bar are also first come first served and offer the full menu.
The Steve and Cookies policy at all bars and oyster bar is that once they fill up, they begin a waitlist.
Check in with the appropriate bartender or host to get your name on a waitlist.Â
Steve and Cookie’s is looking forward to another amazing summer in Margate.
Good luck getting a table. It’s worth the wait.
I was deeply disappointed using Resy to try to make dinner reservations at Steve & Cookies. My daughter really wanted to go there for her 35th birthday. My other daughter and her sister-in-law (who works for Amex so supposedly had some special status) had both pre-filled their resy account with all the required info, including credit card. They both were able to get the reservation we wanted for the desired time. The system then asked for the ccv#, which they tried to promptly put in, but the system hung and wouldn’t take the info. They were then told they had taken too long and timed out and of course when they went back in the reservation was gone. So we went elsewhere.
Oh well, S&C will survive without your dining there. For the record, once logged in I’ve never had an issue getting the time I click on – the challenge is getting the days / times you want given the damned – not the functionality of Resy.